When you embark on learning the guitar, one of the first decisions you’ll face is whether to start with an acoustic, electric, or classical guitar. All types have their unique characteristics and offer different experiences for beginners. In this article, we’ll delve into the differences between acoustic and electric guitars and weigh the pros and cons of each for new learners.
The Fundamental Differences
Acoustic Guitars
Acoustic guitars produce sound through the vibration of the strings, which resonates within the guitar’s hollow body. They are typically made of wood, have steel/metal strings, and are used mainly to play chords and accompanying songs. They do not require external amplification and are often played with a pick. (Taylor Swift plays an acoustic guitar.)
Classical guitars, often called Spanish or Traditional guitars, have a rich history rooted in classical music. Unlike generic acoustic guitars, which typically have steel strings, classical guitars are strung with nylon strings, giving them a softer, mellower sound. The neck of a classical guitar is also wider, allowing for more space between the strings, which can benefit fingerstyle playing. Additionally, classical guitars often have a slotted headstock, a design reminiscent of lutes and early stringed instruments. (Andres Segovia, Manuel Barrueco, David Russell, and many others are famous classical guitarists.)
Electric Guitars
On the other hand, electric guitars rely on electronic pickups to capture the strings’ vibration. The signal is then sent to an amplifier to produce sound. They have a solid body and are known for producing a wide range of tones and effects. (Jimi Hendrix played an electric guitar.)
Pros and Cons for Beginners
Acoustic/Classical Guitars
Pros
- Portability: Acoustic guitars are self-contained and don’t require any additional equipment, making them easy to transport and play anywhere.
- Simplicity: The acoustic guitar offers a straightforward and intuitive design, free from the complexities of electronic components and amplification. For beginners, this simplicity means they can focus solely on mastering the basics of playing without the distractions of adjusting amplifiers, effects, or dealing with cables. This direct, plug-free experience allows new learners to quickly pick up the instrument and start playing, making the learning curve feel more approachable and encouraging consistent practice.
- Versatility in contemporary music genres: Acoustic guitars suit various genres, from folk and country to pop and rock.
- Classical guitars for classical guitar music: Classical guitar music is a rich and intricate genre that spans centuries, encompassing compositions from renowned composers like Francisco Tárrega, Fernando Sor, and Heitor Villa-Lobos. This style of music is characterized by its complex fingerstyle techniques, intricate melodies, and the emotive nuances it demands from the player. For a beginner with a keen interest in classical guitar music, a classical guitar is the best choice. The instrument’s nylon strings produce the soft, warm tones quintessential to the genre, and its wider neck facilitates the precise finger placements required for classical pieces.
Cons
- Finger strength: Acoustic strings can be tougher on the fingers, especially for beginners. This might require a bit more finger strength and dexterity.
- Volume limitations: The volume of an acoustic guitar is limited to its natural resonance. For beginners, this can be a drawback when they wish to play with other louder instruments or perform in larger spaces. Additionally, suppose a learner is trying to develop their dynamics (playing softly versus loudly). In that case, the limited volume range of an acoustic might not offer as much feedback or room for experimentation as an amplified electric guitar would.
Electric Guitars
Pros
- Easier on the fingers: Electric guitars are generally more accessible on the fingers because they typically have lighter gauge strings and lower string action, meaning the strings are closer to the fretboard. This requires less finger pressure to press down on the strings and form chords. This can be particularly beneficial for beginners as it reduces finger fatigue and soreness, allowing for longer practice sessions and a smoother introduction to playing techniques.
- Tonal variety: With the help of amplifiers and effects pedals, electric guitars offer a vast array of sounds and tones. This allows beginners to explore various sounds and styles early on, fostering creativity and helping them find their unique musical voice.
- Volume control: You can easily adjust the volume, making it suitable for quiet practice sessions and louder performances.
Cons
- Requires additional equipment: To get the most out of an electric guitar, you’ll need an amplifier and possibly some effects pedals. This extra equipment can be a drawback for beginners because it means a more costly initial investment. Additionally, setting up and managing this equipment can introduce added complexity, potentially overwhelming newcomers who still need to grasp the basics of the instrument itself.
- Less portability: Due to the need for additional equipment, it’s less convenient to transport and set up compared to an acoustic guitar.
Key Considerations for New Learners
- Budget: Electric guitars might require a more significant initial investment due to the need for amplifiers and other accessories. When choosing your first guitar, factor in all potential costs to make an informed decision that aligns with your budget.
- Music preference: Your preferred music genre can influence your choice. An electric guitar might be more appealing if you’re into rock, blues, or jazz. However, an acoustic might be a better fit if you lean towards folk, country, or singer-songwriter genres. For an aspiring classical guitarist, starting with a classical guitar is crucial to capture the essence and nuances of classical guitar music authentically. Whatever your musical tastes, choosing a guitar that aligns with that can enhance your motivation, enjoyment, and overall learning experience.
- Learning environment: If you’re in a setting where noise might be an issue, an electric guitar with headphones might be ideal for quiet practice. On the other hand, for those who envision playing in various spontaneous settings, like campfires or parks, an acoustic guitar’s portability and plug-free nature offer unmatched convenience and flexibility. Consider where you’ll be learning and practicing to ensure your guitar choice accounts for any space limitations.
Both acoustic and electric guitars have their merits for beginners. Your choice should align with your musical preferences, budget, and where you often see yourself playing. Remember, the most important thing is to enjoy the learning process and the music you create.
Ready to start your guitar journey? Explore our guitar classes here at Levine! We offer private lessons, group classes, ensembles, and jam sessions for guitarists of all styles, ages, and abilities. At each Levine campus in the DC area, our students encounter diverse musical activities, a supportive environment, and dedicated teachers who offer guidance and push creative limits. We also provide online learning!
At Levine Music, our core values—excellence and opportunity—infuse everything we do. Learn more about our program areas and upcoming performances, and donate today to help us bring lifelong joy and inspiration through music!